Andrew Currie on Posterous

Important stuff about mobiles, Linux and copyright... and sometimes not. 
« Back to blog

In case you've ever wondered, this is why Canadian television sucks so bad.

 

Almost without exception, in applying to the CRTC for a TV license or its renewal, they promised the moon in terms of expansive Canadian broadcasting and ended up delivering wall-to-wall U.S. programming. Which is what they intended from the word go. For a very long time in Canada, a TV license was a license to print money.

The quote above comes from Gerald Caplan, who co-chaired a major study of Canadian broadcasting during the Mulroney era of the 1980s. It's taken from a Globe & Mail piece focused on the current spat between broadcasters and cable/satellite companies, but it speaks volumes about the state of television in this country -- specifically the dramatic, fictional-type stuff.

My thoughts on the subject can be summed up thusly: Without a level playing field, we can't win.

Without the barrier to entry of -- oh, I dunno -- another language, English-speaking Canada has neither the resources nor viewers to produce anything comparable to the onslaught of flashy programming from our neighbours to the south.

Our government should be mandating more domestic dramatic programming, but somehow along the way broadcasters were able to bend the rules enough so they could slap the "Canadian content" sticker on things like the six o'clock news, for example. Even worse, because Canadian TV commercials are allowed to air over US shows, there's a whole other industry that cries foul everytime the idea of stricter controls on our airwaves is put forth.

And so today, you have en entire generation of young actors that I've taught at The Second City who's best hope for a career on television in this country is a run of Tim Horton's commercials -- or if they really strike it big, a season or two of a low-budget series on The Comedy Network that nobody will watch, just like I had back in the day.

And that's why I'm packing up my cable box and sending it back to Rogers tomorrow...

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (6)

Oct 25, 2009
and yet I'd still rather watch back to back The Beachcombers than what passes for entertainment from our southern neighbours. We are definitely not in another Golden Age of Television (HBO excepted)
Oct 25, 2009
FishCake said...
Stop watching TV.
Oct 25, 2009
BMac said...
If it helps, I used to watch Improv Heaven and Hell. My favourite part was the end when it was time for the guest to be stuck with the hell (bad) improv. Hilarious!
Oct 25, 2009
MrFlagg said...
the government mandating anything won't work for much longer. TV is headed to being an on demand service and unless the government mandates that home owners must watch X% of Canadian content (which simply won't happen) you won't win.

At the end of the day your real problem is that Canadians don't want their stories retold to them. Like anyone else they want the fantasy of a NCIS:LA and frankly I have trouble seeing CSIS:MB being able to compete.

Oct 25, 2009
Andrew Currie said...
"The government mandating anything won't work for much longer."
It's *never* worked because the government/CRTC/whatever has never grown a pair to do it properly!

I certainly agree with you that the logic would dictate TV going the on-demand route, yet the opposite seems to be true -- look at all those live talent shows with call or text-in results for a limited time immediately afterward...

Nov 15, 2009
Henry Wadsworth said...
CTV and Global... 2 useless stations that need be disolved immediately. They offer nothing creative and unoriginal, and are just pure hijackers of NBC, CBS, FOX and ABC.

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter